Apocalypse Ciao: Italy’s Trump Election

Donald Trump was not on Italy’s ballots. Italians know little of Trump, and little of what they think they know of him is true. But the question that haunted Italy, as well as the world’s political and financial elites ahead of Sunday’s vote, was whether Trump-like popular sentiment would sweep away the cozy arrangements between old-line leftist and rightist parties that have been governing the country.

The result: Trump won big.

Italy’s governing Democratic Party (the Communist Party’s descendant) was reduced to around 18 percent of the vote, cast mostly by government-empowered limousine elites as well as Communist diehards in Tuscany and Emilia. Just as important, voters made it numerically impossible for four-time Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi to repeat the trick he had played on them five years ago, when he delivered his parliamentary contingent to the Left even though he had run on the Right. This time, the voters punished him along with the Left, and effectively ended his corrupt career. Henceforth, Italy’s Right, which racked up about 36 percent of the vote, will be led by the Leaguenationalist conservatives based in the country’s productive north.

The big winner of the night, however, was the “Five Star” movement. This most obviously Trumpian outfit, which expresses the voters’ anger at the establishment, won 33 percent. Its slogan, “Vaffanculo!” none too subtly invites establishmentarians to attempt monogenesis. It took votes primarily from the Left. Moreover, Sunday’s vote changed Italian politics generationally from below. Nothing like this had happened in a century.

That’s the good news.

The bad news is, given Italy’s parliamentary system, the next government’s character will be the result of mostly backroom deals between mostly the usual suspects, including the president of the republic, a Leftist.The election yielded no obvious majority. No Leftist coalition has enough for a majority, even were Berlusconi to join in. A Rightist coalition could get close. The “Five Star” people are averse to coalitions, but might be amenable to abstain in favor of  . . . something. The Left does not want new elections. What will the president try? He has the option of naming a “government of experts,” effectively rescuing the establishment from the electoral drubbing it just got. Italian presidents have done this in the past, at a heavy cost to the political system’s legitimacy.

The latter possibility will become more likely to the extent that financial markets show jitters at the prospect of Italy’s affairs coming into the hands of “unreliable” people, especially ones committed to cutting taxes. Italy’s Right, as well as the “Five Star” movement, are also Euro-skeptical. The prospect of a major European economy arguing with (or disregarding) EU regulations, is also likely to incite Europe’s major vested interests to intercede to try minimizing the election’s effects.

In Italy as elsewhere, the Trump effect is more about attitudes than government programs. That is its strength and its weakness. In Italy, the contrast is best seen in the character of Sunday’s two main winners: The “Five Star” movement’s Luigi Di Maio and the league’s Matteo Salvini. Both have mounted opposition to the past and current government’s facilitation of African/Middle Eastern migration across the Mediterranean. But they shaped the public mind very differently, with Di Maio damning and Salvini explaining.

The same goes for other parts of the party platforms. Emphasis on attitude brought the “Five Stars” the enthusiastic support of young people—some 80 percent of first time voters chose them—as well as votes from the country’s economically depressed regions. But Salvini’s relentless explanations earned the League the support of more mature voters—as shown in its higher figures for the Senate, to vote for which one must be older. Just as important, Salvini managed to become that rare politician to whom people actually listen. The future seems to be looking his way.

The day’s biggest loser by far, Matteo Renzi, the Democratic Party’s president, former prime minister, and recently the international Left’s Boy Wonder, the Italian Obama, best summed up what happened. The entire world has been infected by what Renzi calls a “populist virus,” which first manifested itself in the British people’s decision to leave the European Union and whose virulence elected Donald Trump. That same “virus” now has spread to Italy. There was nothing that Renzi or anyone else could have done to stop it. Of course, one could just as easily argue that the populism Renzi and his comrades despise isn’t a disease so much as a much-needed cure.

The truth, however, has nothing to do with any “ism” or with Trump: when voters are ruled by officials and associated corporate types who despise them, sooner or later they will find ways of returning the favor.

About Angelo Codevilla

Angelo M. Codevilla was a distinguished fellow of the Center for American Greatness. He was professor of international relations at Boston University and the author of several books including To Make And Keep Peace (Hoover Institution Press, 2014).

Support Free & Independent Journalism Your support helps protect our independence so that American Greatness can keep delivering top-quality, independent journalism that's free to everyone. Every contribution, however big or small, helps secure our future. If you can, please consider a recurring monthly donation.

Want news updates?

Sign up for our newsletter to stay up to date.

9 responses to “Apocalypse Ciao: Italy’s Trump Election”

  1. May the virus continue to strengthen and spread until no one who despises the voters he claims to represent is able to win an election.

  2. The left is getting drubbed all over the map, will they go quietly?

    • Does the Left ever do anything quietly when they’re not in control?

  3. When the governments, who are suppose to be protecting them from invasions, literally flood their own countries with barbaric savages, these people who call populism a virus should be very grateful the people are so incredibly civilized and patient, that they trust elections still, instead of hanging them on lampposts!

  4. A fantastic analysis by the always-brilliant Codevilla. I think that were the President to form a government that bypasses the people’s choice (which was loud and clear), his warmed-up Communist party would lose even bigger in the next elections. The Brussels-puppets Monti, Letta and Renzi, along with his right-hand henchwoman Boldrini of “immigrants are resources” fame, have actively ruled against the Italian people for too long, and the country’s political mood is at a fever pitch.

    The larger issue is that the people in many European countries are now realizing that the EU has become a tiger held by its tail. It has replaced democracy with the most opaque and Byzantine bureaucracy that could be devised (and exactly on purpose), so that a self-perpetuating imperial technocracy-from-afar wouldn’t have to bother with election results. Many want to leave it, but the EU system has made it exceedingly costly and complicated to do so. Mass third-world immigration imposed from the top is the suicidal policy that will either kill the EU (as I fervently hope) or turn European countries with millennia’s worth of individual history into depressing slums that look and feel all the same.

    Bottom line: what lamp-post ornaments like Renzi, Merkel and Junkers call “populism” is nothing but good old democracy: the people taking control of their country’s destiny. The alternative is a self-described professional class that is turning out to be the most incompetent and unenlightened since the Athenian bunch who sentenced Socrates to die of the hemlock.

  5. Thank God! The World is waking up to the Corruption of the Communist/Leftist! May all the Hillary’s and Obama’s of the World burn!

  6. I find it somewhat remarkable that the supposed elite still haven’t figured this out. They may yet figure out that eventually the people you consistently ignore will stop voting and consider other options. This is one of the constants of history. Perhaps the eleites aren’t so elite after all.

  7. “…invites establishmentarians to attempt monogenesis”

    Such an elegant translation!

    • Also somewhat inaccurate. Vafancuolo! (contraction of va: go, fa: make, un: a, and cuolo: hole, does not mean “Go **** yourself!” but, instead, “Show [us] your [posterior] hole!”