TEXT JOIN TO 77022

The End of Suicidal Universalism

Much of the friction Trump has with the governing class arises from his rejection of universalism, the metaprinciple at the heart of liberalism. This principle declares that one’s brother, father, wife, child, neighbor, countryman, coreligionist, or fellow tribe member are all supposed to be treated no differently from an absolute stranger. For universalists, those naturally closer to us have no priority claims upon our time and resources, and it is unfair and discriminatory to proceed otherwise. After all, we are all human beings.

In the spirit of universalism, we have been taught for many years that America is chiefly an idea or a creed, but these teachers forget to acknowledge that we are also a particular people with a shared history and a shared ancestry living on a particular piece of geography . . . in other words, a nation.

For the universalists, our country is just a grab bag, a money machine for do-gooderism and, more often than not, do-badderism.

NGOs Fuel Mass Illegal Immigration

Universalism ain’t cheap. The waves of illegals who arrived under Joe Biden depend upon an extensive network of nonprofits, NGOs, foundations, charities, and other institutions that paved the way for their arrival, helped them get government aid, or sometimes directly gave them money with no conditions, and collectively have done absolutely nothing to strengthen our country or improve the lot of citizens.

This collection of nonprofits, government-funded NGOs, and charities has become a parallel path for the managerial class, a place to make a living or kill time between administrations. The estimable Z Man has presciently described this ring of organizations as a “shadow government.” Not merely helping refugees, these institutions also engage in other activities important to the government, like fomenting color revolutions abroad and disseminating COVID propaganda at home.

While ostensibly neutral and separate from the government, these cutouts are paid to conduct studies that support government policies, as in the case of foreign “independent” media funded by the U.S. Government, and otherwise to do the government’s bidding with less accountability. Real war nerds may remember a classic example, the idiotic “NAFO” trolling campaign in support of American efforts in Ukraine.

When Trump decreed a pause in government funding of nonprofits to evaluate conformity to his agenda—until foiled by the courts—it quickly created chaos. Perhaps this was by design. While the pause led to some pushback about its scope, the tumult has also exposed the nature and extent of the enormous, parasitical world of government-funded nonprofits.

It turns out a whole bunch of people are on the gravy train, and, without ongoing funding, these organizations would have to fold up the tents, and their people would have to find remunerative, private-sector employment. Much of this work lacks parallels in the for-profit sector, and many of these people are otherwise unemployable because they are ideological true believers and absolute weirdos. Some will drop out from the white-collar middle class into something like waiting tables or working in factories if this funding goes away. Pity.

The funding cut does not merely restrain “woke” stuff. The federal government’s budget is out of hand, having reached astronomical levels during the COVID pandemic. This is why cutting government jobs, which Trump’s voluntary buyout policy will encourage, is not enough.

Most of the government’s money is spent and wasted through contracts with private companies and nonprofits, both large and small, for everything from refugee settlement and “independent media” in Ukraine to endless efforts at COVID education, even now, years after the end of the pandemic.

The portion of that money spent subsidizing an army of unskilled, unemployed, and hostile foreigners is a perverse mockery of what every government is supposed to do. Rather than contributing to the public good, the immigration nonprofits exist to hurt us by facilitating the mass migration of extremely alien foreigners in order to devolve the remaining fragments of national unity that have survived the social changes of the last 50 years. The least we can do is make them pay their own way.

Arguments that this is all some type of noble charity work that we are morally obliged to continue ad infinitum are now falling on deaf ears.

A False Morality is Fueling National Destruction

One of the dumber ideas to grow out of the post-9/11 Global War on Terrorism was the notion that because we had ourselves established a free and democratic government that protected natural rights, somehow we were obliged to export this model of government to the whole world, even in the face of violent resistance.

Missing from this crusading idea was any recognition of the human terrain. People are different. Fitness for self-government depends upon certain traits of culture and character that are themselves revealed only when such a government is a product of a people’s own efforts and struggles. The democracies we imposed on Iraq and Afghanistan quickly became illiberal and unstable because they were not the product of an organic growth but were instead imposed upon them by an overly idealistic and hubristic United States.

The same hubris lies behind much of the immigration-charity industrial complex. Advocates conflate our obligations to foreigners with our obligations to our neighbors and to our people. Indeed, they reverse these obligations because the people running these operations are not merely indifferent but actively hostile to Americans and their welfare.

We saw this hostility vividly in the Biden administration’s utter failure to assist the people of North Carolina after the devastating floods, even while boatloads of money were spent on assisting illegal immigrants to thrive and pursue fraudulent asylum claims.

Everything the government does needs to be subject to a microscope and to the scythe. In other words, everything it does and funds should be presumptively shut down until examined very closely and proven to be necessary. We are no longer as wealthy in relative terms as we once were, and, even if we could afford all of these things, a government is not supposed to undermine its own people’s welfare to benefit another’s in the pursuit of a false morality that puts strangers above one’s own community.

Christianity does not require the destruction of nations. While a certain amount of universalism is presaged by the Christian faith, the individual obligations we have to the poor as Christians cannot be made abstract and taken over by a behemoth, managerial state. Rather, charity must spring from the heart and be limited by countervailing obligations to those whom one is commanded by scripture to look after first: one’s family, one’s children, and one’s nation.

***

Christopher Roach is an adjunct fellow of the Center for American Greatness and an attorney in private practice based in Florida. He is a double graduate of the University of Chicago and has previously been published by The Federalist, Takimag, Chronicles, the Washington Legal Foundation, the Marine Corps Gazette, and the Orlando Sentinel. The views presented are solely his own.

Get the news corporate media won't tell you.

Get caught up on today's must read stores!

By submitting your information, you agree to receive exclusive AG+ content, including special promotions, and agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms. By providing your phone number and checking the box to opt in, you are consenting to receive recurring SMS/MMS messages, including automated texts, to that number from my short code. Msg & data rates may apply. Reply HELP for help, STOP to end. SMS opt-in will not be sold, rented, or shared.

About Christopher Roach

Christopher Roach is an adjunct fellow of the Center for American Greatness and an attorney in private practice based in Florida. He is a double graduate of the University of Chicago and has previously been published by The Federalist, Takimag, Chronicles, the Washington Legal Foundation, the Marine Corps Gazette, and the Orlando Sentinel. The views presented are solely his own.

Photo: United States american usa us flag on flagpole textile cloth fabric waving on the top sunrise mist fog

Notable Replies

  1. Avatar for Alecto Alecto says:

    I wonder if this was prompted by J.D. Vance’s mention of the Catholic principle of Ordo Amoris during an interview recently? In relation to immigration, that principle is critical to the survival of the United States. Americans must put their families first, their people and cities or towns. That principle explains why, without being educated in the Catholic church, or ever having learned Latin, millions of people care for elderly parents, friends and neighbors and why so many real “charities” are private, individual efforts aimed locally with neighbors helping neighbors. Charitable people don’t need tax exemptions to do good for others. They certainly don’t need government contracts. For years, NGOs have misled Americans about the “charitable” aspect of their work. They are anything but “charitable”. They are grifting devils, undermining everything Americans love about this country, and they make war on American citizens.

    Among the endless need for reform within government, I sincerely hope and pray that a very long investigation and deep purge or total elimination of the IRS takes place over the next four years. Far from being the agency which collects taxes or explains tax code, the IRS is an armed camp of terrorists, as any small business person can describe.

  2. Avatar for task task says:

    Years ago an immigrant from Columbia told me that he feels sorry for old Americans. In Columbia, where he was raised, in a small community, a widow or widower would be cared for by many in the community who invite them into their homes each night where they are showered with attention and care. It is more than a singular cultural thing because all cultures, except for some Eskimo cultures, do this instinctively. As a rather physically weak species, our success is dependent upon strong social bonding and interactions. And, what should be obvious, and is, in so many societies, in so many ways, is that we don’t automatically extend such friendly behavior to foreigners who more than just speak different languages we do not understand but also engage in cultural practices we sometimes discover to be downright abhorrent. We are an extremely competitive species. Our altruistic behavior is based upon necessity and an organic desire to improve our immediate group – that concept had a lot to do with the reasoning behind the origin of the Tenth Amendment.

    A friend of mind, a priest, who did the final benediction at the inauguration, with probably thousands of sermons under his belt is a border hawk. Of course he is a Christian but clearly sees Christianity as weaponized and used by politicians to achieve a globalist Marxist agenda. We were better off before the Bill of Rights, and especially the First Amendment, was thrust upon all the States as part of the post Civil War peace settlement. Think about Jefferson’s letter to the Danbury Baptists. He was right nevertheless, today, a Nativity Scene, which should be far removed from politics, is looked upon as a violation of the First Amendment by the progressive radicals yet fleecing the taxpayers to support enemies of America, via the USAID, is considered Constitutional and necessary. In reality they know what they are doing and have every intention of continuing to scam whether it be by financing another Green New Deal or another war to achieve anti-American agendas.

  3. Avatar for task task says:

    Trump is using tariffs to reduce the Income Tax burden. Both the Department of Education and the 16th Amendment are squarely in his sights. We have had a long period of engagement and experience with these Constitutional aberrant offspring and we now know that they clearly do what so many other things government also does. And they do it in a very big way. They do the very opposite of what was intended. So much is now by design but much of what has gone wrong, which we are currently dealing with, associated with taxes and education, is the result of the “Law of Unintended Consequences”.

  4. Americans are the most charitable people in the world, so the philosophical underpinning for the existence of an agency like USAID to redress this imaginary deficiency was really about bankrupting the US. It’s an article of faith among leftists that this project will eventually put them in complete control. They dream that elections might even be done away with. It’s the guiding light behind why Democrats created this and other unaccountable bureaucracies. The philosophy behind their creation also brought in millions of needy unemployable people who can be used to vote Democrat.

    Trump and DOGE will end Democrats’ and their leftist allies’ daydreams by side-stepping leftist judges’ edicts and seizing the computers of agencies like USAID that are used to send our money into oblivion. USAID is an example of leftist illusion and myopia on steroids.

  5. Avatar for task task says:

    We hope that Trump and DOGE end sidestepping Original Intent and the efforts to undermine the Constitution but never underestimate Republican efforts to resuscitate and revive those willing to destroy America based on some political litmus test used to measure ideological purity. That is why Trump is the perfect President for these times. He has no problem, after four years of political persecution, to drive stakes right into the center of their evil hearts to ascertain that they can’t be resurrected.

Continue the discussion at community.amgreatness.com

Participants

Avatar for afhack73 Avatar for Alecto Avatar for task Avatar for system